Skip to content
Oil Change International | Data Driven, People Powered. Oil Change International | Data Driven, People Powered.
  • About
    • Our Work
    • Values
    • Team
    • Jobs at OCI
    • Ways to Give
  • Program Areas
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • North Sea
    • United States
    • Global Industry
    • Global Public Finance
    • Global Policy
  • Blog
  • Press Releases
  • Publications
Donate
  • Get Updates
    • Share on Bluesky Share on Bluesky Bluesky (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Twitter Share on Twitter Twitter (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Instagram Share on Instagram Instagram (opens in a new window)
    • Share on LinkedIn Share on LinkedIn LinkedIn (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Facebook Share on Facebook Facebook (opens in a new window)
Donate
  • About
    • Our Work
    • Values
    • Team
    • Jobs at OCI
    • Ways to Give
  • Program Areas
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • North Sea
    • United States
    • Global Industry
    • Global Public Finance
    • Global Policy
  • Blog
  • Press Releases
  • Publications
    • Get Updates
    • Share on Bluesky Bluesky
    • Share on Twitter Twitter
    • Share on Instagram Instagram
    • Share on LinkedIn LinkedIn
    • Share on Facebook Facebook
Go to OCI Homepage
Current Affairs
Published: January 14, 2011

EPA 1: Big Coal 0

  • Latest from OCI
  • Blogs listing
  • EPA 1: Big Coal 0
    • Blog Post Coal Current Affairs Featured Mountain-top removal Pollution US politics
Andy Rowell

When not blogging for OCI, Andy is a freelance writer and journalist specializing in environmental issues.

[email protected]

So its game on. The EPA may be under attack from the Republicans, but its not rolling over and waiting to be stripped of its powers, without a fight.

It is taking on Big Coal in the battle over mountain top removal.

In what is being seen as an historic decision, the EPA has said it will be revoking the permit granted to the Mingo-Logan  Spruce Number One mine in West Virginia.

Mingo Logan is a subsidiary of Arch Coal, Inc., the second largest U.S. coal producer.

A Clean Water Act permit for the mine was originally issued in 2007 under the Bush Government.

The agency said it was the first time it had revoked a previously issued permit in 40 years, but it said the action was warranted because the environmental damage was truly “unacceptable”.

EPA officials said they only made the decision after extensive scientific study, a major public hearing in West Virginia and review of more than 50,000 public comments.

Moreover after year-long discussions with the company, it had failed to produce an agreement that would lead to a significant decrease in impacts to the environment and Appalachian communities.

The EPA said the mine would have dumped millions of tons of mining waste into healthy waterways, burying 6.6 miles of streams and completely killing off fish, and other wildlife.

“The proposed Spruce Number One mine would use destructive and unsustainable mining practices that jeopardise the health of Appalachian communities and clean water on which they depend,” the agency’s assistant administrator for water Peter Silva said in a statement. “We have a responsibility under the law to protect water quality and safeguard the people who rely on clean water.”

The decision certainly raises the stakes between the EPA and the coal-friendly Republicans, and already it has evoked a strong reaction from the West Virginian coal lobby.

The local Democrats are not too happy, either: West Virginia’s newly elected Democratic senator, Joe Manchin, who had run a campaign showing him using EPA regulations as target practice, said the decision would have a “chilling” effect on the economy.

“Today’s EPA decision is not just fundamentally wrong, it is an unprecedented act by the federal government that will cost our state and our nation even more jobs during the worst recession in this country’s history,” Manchin said.

But Joe would say that – to see how much Big Coal lines his pockets, go here.

The local nonprofit Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition was pleased, though “The science completely validates what we have been saying for more than a decade – these types of mining operations are destroying our streams and forests and nearby residents’ health, and even driving entire communities to extinction. This type of steep slope coal mining is destroying our cultural heritage and our future.”

Jon Devine of the Natural Resources Defence Council added: “In the face of the political and industrial forces pressuring EPA to ignore the damage this mine would cause, it took guts for the agency to follow the science and the law.”

Oil Change International | Data Driven, People Powered.
Donate Get Updates
Back to the top
  • Keep in touch

  • Oil Change International
    714 G St. SE, #202
    Washington, DC 20003
    United States

    +1.202.518.9029

    [email protected]

    • Share on Bluesky Bluesky (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Twitter Twitter (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Instagram Instagram (opens in a new window)
    • Share on LinkedIn LinkedIn (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Facebook Facebook (opens in a new window)
  • Quick links

  • About OCI
  • Our Values
  • Jobs at OCI
  • Ways to Give
  • Media Centre

  • Publications
  • Press
  • Associated websites

  • Big Oil Reality Check
  • Energy Finance Database
  • Permian Climate Bomb
  • Site map
  • Privacy policy

Copyright © 2025 Oil Change International. Web design by Fat Beehive